Skip to content

Photo courtesy of Highways Today

A recent panel discussion on Investment Law and Environmental Protection: Some Lessons for Sri Lanka at took me back to a question that has remained central to my research over the past few years: what happens when law attempts to protect nature while continuing to conceptualise nature as an object of human use?

With the advent of the new Sri Lanka’s National Mineral Policy 2026 and the broader discussions on mineral mining, this question has acquired renewed relevance. On August 25, the Petroleum Development Authority officially launched the oil exploration license round for the Mannar Basin. In this piece, I will not dwell on the policy or the developments on oil exploration because my focus is on understanding the epistemology (or the thinking) behind resource governance in general that is at the centre of many of these developments.

Mineral governance is plagued with an inherent tension. On the one hand, minerals are understood as finite resources. Some argue that this necessitates responsible and sustainable management of mineral resources. On the other, they remain framed as national wealth, whose value is to be identified, utilised and converted into economic benefit. Critical legal scholars considers these views as anthropocentric or human-centred.  This raises two obvious questions: whether within the present legal framework, we are able to reconcile these competing ideas; and whether the law can view, understand and conceptualise the human relationship with the natural world in a non-anthropocentric manner.

The new policy identifies several key concerns including sustainable management of mineral resources and the environment, value addition to mineral exports, mineral-related industrial development and the exploration and extraction of seabed mineral resources. It also frames the state as having responsibility to understand and manage national mineral wealth while conserving the environment. The policy is said to be grounded under the theme of “Sustainable Resource Utilization – Maximum Benefit Generation” as stated in the government’s policy statement “A Thriving Nation – A Beautiful Life”.

The nature-culture divide within the law

Legal systems constructs nature and humans as two separate domains. Nature exists outside culture while human beings occupy the realm of reason/rationality. This thinking makes it possible to conceptualise nature as resources, rivers as water systems, minerals as commodities and most importantly land as property. Nature becomes property that can be owned, regulated, extracted and also conserved. The ultimate decision is vested with the human because the human is more rational and thereby knows best. Absolute sovereign ownership of natural resources of the state also emerges from this thinking. Anna Grear, a critical legal scholar, calls this “the anthropocentric closures of the liberal legal order”, which in other words translates into the idea of who, what and whose interests we count within the law ultimately stemming from the very idea of viewing nature as an object of human use.

International environmental law has undoubtedly complicated this relationship. Principles such as sustainable development, polluter pays, precaution and intergenerational equity have introduced important limitations on the unfettered exploitation of natural resources. However, critics argue that it is still based on the dualistic thinking of viewing nature as an object. Environmental Impact Assessment (EIAs), a key environmental management tool we use in environmental development, emerges from the precautionary principle. The issue however is that even EIAs lies within a framework in which nature remains an object under human control.

Even the language underlying the human right to a clean and healthy environment, despite its considerable normative and practical importance, contains this tension. While the human right to a clean and healthy environment strengthens environmental protection and environmental rights of marginalised and vulnerable communities, it has been critiqued for placing humans at the centre of environmental protection. Due to its inherent universalising language, which runs the risk of overlooking specific concerns of communities, including Indigenous groups who share a distinct relationship with nature, in academic discussions scholars pinpoint at the need for constact scrutiny to avoid simply greening of an essentially anthropocentric legal framework.

Lessons from mining in Ecuador’s Los Cedros forest

If treating nature as an object within the law is problematic, then could we make nature a subject with legal rights within the existing system? Unfortunately, it is more complicated that that and like many issues in environmental protection there are no straightforward answers.

In Ecuador, the constitutional recognition of the rights of Pachamama (an Indigenous conception that translates as rights of mother earth) has enabled courts to recognise nature as subjects of rights. The Right of Nature jurisprudence has disrupted the conventional nature – culture binary. A forest is no longer merely a resource because nature is treated also as a legal subject with its own ecological integrity. In the Los Cedros case, the Ecuadorian Constitutional Court recognised that Los Cedros, a protected primary forest, was a subject of rights.

However, Ecuador is also crucial to recall that Rights of Nature does not smoothly transition the law from anthropocentrism to ecocentrism. Especially in mining, the use of Rights of Nature must be done with caution. Changing the legal subject does not necessarily transform the power relations through which law operates. New concepts can be absorbed into existing legal structures without fundamentally disrupting their underlying assumptions about nature. While the constitution recognised the rights of Pachamama, the same legal system also recognises that mining corporations have right to property. Corporations are also legal persons and by way of being legal persons is entitled to make investments controlling the nature with permits from the state. In these cases, the court is essentially balancing the rights of several legal persons with dispropotionate power. Nature, often under the stewardship of Indigenous groups or local communities have much less bargaining power, in comparision to powerful corporations, which are sometimes even more powerful than the state itself.

Mineral policy and the legal imagination of nature

The National Mineral Policy 2026 recognises the need for sustainable management, environmental conservation and rehabilitation and expressly considers land-related issues and the environmental dimensions of mineral extraction. At the same time, it seeks to optimise the use and benefits of local minerals, promote value addition and develop mineral-related industries. Within the policy nature remains situated within a framework of resource governance. It is a familiar sequence: the mineral deposit is identified as part of the country’s mineral wealth. The state determines its potential as the absolute sovereign. Investors and industries determine its economic value. Environmental regulation then establishes the conditions under which extraction may occur. At all levels, nature remains an object.

 

The question, therefore, is not simply whether Sri Lanka can develop/utilise its mineral resources in a more sustainable manner; it is whether the legal framework through which we understand and govern those resources is capable of moving beyond the anthropocentric assumptions that have historically shaped our relationship with nature. If the nature-culture divide continues to position humans as the rational subjects of law and nature as the object of human decision making, then even our most progressive environmental safeguards may remain confined within the same conceptual boundaries.

A more relational approach to mineral governance would require us to ask a different question: when nature enters the legal imagination, must it always enter as a resource? This is the more fundamental question emerging from the discussions about Sri Lanka’s mineral future. The policy conversation should not simply be about regulating extraction better in order to truly factor in ecological integrity; it should reconsider the legal imagination that makes extraction possible in the first place.

The author is a researcher and an Attorney-at-Law in Sri Lanka.  She is also a visiting lecturer for environmental law at the University of Peradeniya.