Photo courtesy of Daily Mirror
For most of the year, Kachchathivu is little more than a windswept patch of coral rock in the Palk Strait – dry, uninhabited and geopolitically sensitive. Naval patrols monitor the surrounding waters. Fishermen measure distance carefully. Diplomats cite agreements signed half a century ago.
But for two days each year, the island transforms. Nearly 4,000 pilgrims from India crossed the narrow stretch of sea to attend the feast of Anthony of Padua, the beloved patron saint of fishermen. They arrived in boats from Rameswaram and surrounding coastal villages. Sri Lankan worshippers from the Jaffna peninsula joined them. Mass was conducted in Tamil. Candles flickered against the sea breeze. Fishermen prayed for safe voyages, bountiful catches and protection from arrest as much as from storms.
For a brief moment, the maritime boundary softened. Yet beneath the hymns lies a charged reality. The feast unfolds at a time when Kachchathivu has re-emerged as a potent symbol in Tamil Nadu politics. Actor turned politician Vijay Chandrasekar is reshaping the state’s political imagination. Meanwhile, the BJP is positioning itself as a rising force in a state long dominated by Dravidian parties. And at the center of the symbolism stand fishing communities from both India and Sri Lanka, struggling against ecological depletion and economic precarity. The feast of St. Antony is not merely devotional. It is a lens through which sovereignty, electoral ambition and survival intersect.
Kachchathivu lies between Rameswaram in Tamil Nadu and Sri Lanka’s northern coast near Jaffna. In 1974, India signed an agreement formally recognizing Sri Lankan sovereignty over the island. A subsequent 1976 agreement demarcated maritime boundaries more clearly, limiting cross border fishing access. At the time, Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi framed the decision as a gesture of regional goodwill. The island was considered strategically minor – a barren rock – and its transfer was seen as strengthening diplomatic ties. Crucially, the 1974 agreement preserved traditional access for Indian pilgrims to attend the annual feast without visa requirements. Religious continuity was maintained even as fishing rights became restricted. But what was once treated as a minor diplomatic adjustment has grown into a powerful political narrative in Tamil Nadu.
The waters around Kachchathivu tell a different story from the one spoken in campaign speeches. On the Sri Lankan side, northern Tamil fishermen endured decades of restriction during the civil war. Large stretches of coast were designated high security zones. After 2009, when the conflict ended, they returned to sea hoping to rebuild their livelihoods.
What they found were mechanized Indian trawlers operating extensively in waters they considered their own. Bottom trawling – dragging weighted nets across the seabed – has been widely criticized for destroying coral reefs and breeding grounds, depleting shrimp and high value species and undermining traditional small scale fishing
Sri Lankan Tamil fishermen argue that their small boats cannot compete with industrial trawlers. They demand enforcement. The Sri Lankan Navy has responded with arrests and vessel seizures. On the Indian side, fishermen from Rameswaram tell a parallel story of decline. Fish stocks closer to shore have diminished. Many boat owners carry heavy debts. Crossing into Sri Lankan waters becomes an economic calculation rather than an act of defiance. Thus, two vulnerable fishing populations, culturally connected and often related, find themselves positioned as adversaries.
During the St. Antony’s feast, these tensions recede, although temporarily. Pilgrims line up at naval checkpoints before disembarking. Indian and Sri Lankan flags are visible. Security personnel maintain order. Yet once mass begins, divisions blur. Tamil hymns rise across the island. Fishermen exchange stories of lost nets and lost relatives. Families share meals under makeshift tents. Vows are offered for safe return from sea. For a brief window, Kachchathivu becomes a sacred commons, a space where identity as Tamil Catholics and seafarers supersedes national boundary. It is perhaps the only moment in the year when cooperation seems effortless.
Into this delicate landscape entered Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who recently revived the Kachchathivu issue during India’s election season. He criticized the Congress Party for giving away the island, framing it as a failure of national resolve.
The move surprised many in Sri Lanka, where the matter is regarded as legally settled. But in Tamil Nadu, the issue resonates emotionally. Coastal constituencies have long expressed frustration over fishermen arrests and maritime restrictions. By invoking Kachchathivu, the BJP inserts itself directly into a narrative historically dominated by Dravidian parties.
The strategy serves multiple purposes: undermining Congress by revisiting Indira Gandhi’s decision, pressuring the ruling DMK by recalling its historical alignment with Congress, appealing to fishermen’s grievances and positioning BJP as a defender of sovereignty.
Importantly, the BJP’s growing visibility in Tamil Nadu signals a broader shift. Although historically marginal in the state, it has increased its vote share in recent elections and is actively cultivating regional issues to challenge traditional dominance. Kachchathivu becomes not merely a maritime question but a symbol of BJP’s southern ambition.
Actor Vijay’s political entry adds another layer. Unlike the BJP’s nationalistic framing, Vijay’s appeal rests on Tamil identity, youth mobilization and anti-establishment rhetoric. His references to fishermen’s welfare resonate strongly in coastal belts.
However, his position on Kachchathivu remains carefully measured. Openly aligning with BJP’s sovereignty rhetoric risks conflating Tamil rights with central government nationalism. Ignoring the issue risks appearing detached from fishermen’s concerns. Vijay’s political challenge is to move the conversation from symbolic reclamation to structural reform: debt relief, sustainable fishing transition and bilateral cooperation. Whether he can convert symbolic politics into policy clarity remains to be seen. For decades, Tamil Nadu politics has been shaped by Dravidian ideological currents. The BJP was often perceived as peripheral. That perception is shifting. By directly engaging emotionally charged regional issues such as fishermen arrests, Tamil dignity and maritime sovereignty, the BJP is embedding itself within the state’s political vocabulary. Even if reclaiming Kachchathivu is diplomatically improbable, raising the issue forces opponents to respond. It expands BJP’s presence in discourse, if not immediately in legislative power.
The feast at Kachchathivu unfolded amid a subtle reconfiguration of Tamil Nadu’s political landscape. Yet beyond the speeches lies a deeper problem. The Palk Strait is ecologically fragile. Coral reefs, seagrass beds and spawning grounds sustain fish populations vital to both India and Sri Lanka. Scientists warn that continued bottom trawling could irreversibly damage marine ecosystems.
If fish stocks collapse, Sri Lankan small scale fishermen lose income, the Tamil Nadu trawler fleets become economically unsustainable and political rhetoric becomes irrelevant.
Reclaiming territory does not regenerate coral. National pride does not restore depleted stocks.
The crisis demands gradual phasing out of bottom trawlers, investment in deep sea fishing alternatives, joint conservation zones and structured bilateral dialogue involving fisher associations.
These solutions are complex and politically costly. They lack the emotional immediacy of sovereignty claims. Much of the dispute has operated through “power over” – arrests, naval enforcement and political accusations. The feast, however, embodies “power with.” For two days, states coordinate peacefully, communities gather without hostility and shared identity overrides division.
The island demonstrates that cooperation is not utopian; it is practiced annually. The question is whether this cooperative ethos can extend beyond ritual into fisheries governance. Sri Lanka’s leadership has publicly downplayed election rhetoric from India. But concerns linger. When national leaders reopen settled issues, even symbolically, diplomatic trust can erode. Sri Lankan fishermen, particularly in Jaffna, view enforcement as necessary for survival. Any perception of political leniency risks local backlash. The delicate balance between diplomacy and domestic accountability remains fragile. As the final mass concluded, pilgrims boarded boats homeward. They carried blessed candles, rosaries and stories of fellowship. But they also return to contested waters where arrests may resume and economic strain persists.
Kachchathivu stands as paradox. It is a site of shared devotion, a symbol in electoral campaigns, a flashpoint in maritime enforcement and a reminder of ecological interdependence.
For Tamil Nadu politicians, whether BJP leaders asserting sovereignty or Vijay cultivating Tamil rights, the island represents opportunity. For fishermen on both shores, it represents livelihood. And for the environment beneath the waves, it represents a warning. Faith flows freely across the Palk Strait. Fish do not. Unless politics moves beyond symbolism toward cooperative stewardship, the sacred waters of Kachchathivu will remain contested seas.