Photo courtesy of Vikalpa
By the end of February, the window for public comments on Sri Lanka’s draft Protection of the State from Terrorism Act of 2026 (PSTA) was officially closed. This draft law intends to replace Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act No. 48 of 1979 (PTA), the draconian counter-terrorism law currently in force that received significant criticism over decades for a range of concerns including its role in fuelling a significant number of torture cases. The preamble of the draft law appears to be an attempt to directly address a central critique of the current counter-terrorism regime by acknowledging the need to balance humane treatment and human dignity with public safety. But does it truly deliver on that promise?
Sri Lanka’s obligation to uphold humane treatment and human dignity is anchored in the freedom from torture, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, a prohibition so fundamental that cannot be limited or suspended under any circumstances. As a party to the International Convention on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the Convenant against Torture and its Optional Protocol (OPCAT), Sri Lanka carries a duty to prevent, investigate and respond to torture. These binding commitments are reinforced by influential soft law standards such as the Nelson Mandela Rules, which set the modern benchmark for the treatment of prisoners. Together they form a framework that requires Sri Lanka not only to eliminate torture and other ill-treatment but to ensure, in practice, that every person deprived of liberty is treated with dignity. The freedom from torture and other ill-treatment is also recognised as a fundamental right with no restrictions, guaranteed for everyone, under Article 11 of the Constitution of Sri Lanka.
While the draft law gestures towards progress from the current PTA in the battle against torture by delivering on these obligations yet the question remains whether it has it struck the right balance between humane treatment and public security as it expressly claims to do.
Some notable improvements
Compared to the current PTA, the draft law reflects some progress. It recognises that the places of detention under the Act should have humane conditions. Echoing the reforms introduced to the PTA in 2022, the PSTA recognises the role of the magistrate to prevent torture and other ill-treatment by conducting monthly visits to places of detention and taking action when any signs of ill-treatment are noticed. Seeking to distance itself from the one of the most controversial legacies of the current counter-terrorism framework, the admissibility of confessions in court, the draft law requires that statements are made before a magistrate to ensure their admissibility, with tighter restrictions. Yet whether these safeguards will prove meaningful practice in preventing the torture and ill-treatment it may indirectly warrant remains uncertain.
The role of the Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka (HRCSL) is improved under the draft law. It provides for the HRCSL to be notified of arrests, for representatives of the commission without any advance notice to visit and inspect places of detention and inform the Inspector General of Police of their observations. Yet it doesn’t expressly recognise the HRCSL’s powerful mandate as the National Preventive Mechanism under OPCAT, which goes beyond merely carrying out unnoticed visits and inspecting places of detention and interviewing suspects. For example, its role to maintain dialogue with the authorities on the treatment of detainees is not adequately reflected. It arguably represents a missed opportunity to formally and directly recognise its crucial independent oversight role.
The broad definition of terrorism
The key challenge regarding counter-terrorism legislations in general is how the crime of terrorism is defined. Although there is no universally accepted definition for the term, any attempt to define it as a crime must meet standards of clarity, precision and foreseeability as required by Article 15 of the ICCPR and the best practices relating to protecting human rights in the context of counter-terrorism (A/HRC/16/51 as updated by A/HRC/61/52). Examined against those standards, the PSTA’s definition of terrorism in Section 3 is still vague and broad despite being an improvement from the PTA. This definition covers several vague terms, such as hurt, propagating war and serious obstruction of IT services. The ambiguous wording leaves room for justification of unwarranted interventions on people’s fundamental freedoms.
Over decades, Sri Lanka has lived through the line between security and repression being blurred via overbroad definitions. We have witnessed the deliberate or inadvertent misuse of the PTA or emergency regimes that had similar ambiguity relating to the prohibited conduct. The risks of broad wording extend beyond legal uncertainty to fuelling stigma and dehumanisation.
When crimes are defined broadly they create space for abuse, increasing the risk of violence, including torture and other ill-treatment. Labelling an act as terrorism signals that ordinary criminal law is insufficient to deal with it as the conduct is exceptionally grave. Once the label is applied, the society tends to see the suspect not as a person presumed innocent until proven guilty but as a dangerous other. This is where dehumanisation begins. People already view criminal suspects as deviants but the stigma intensifies when the alleged offence is framed as a threat to national security. Therefore, when the definition of terrorism is vague, almost anyone could fall within it and be seen as a deviant and be subject to stigma. When someone is seen as less deserving of dignity, the public may become more willing, sometimes more unconsciously, to tolerate violence against them, including torture and other ill-treatment.
This endeavour to replace the PTA is an opportunity to reflect on the lessons learned from our troubled past and adopted a more narrowly framed definition of terrorism with clearer intent and purpose. Otherwise Sri Lanka risks repeating patterns it has struggled for decades to move beyond.
Specific safeguards against torture and other ill-treatment
The draft law indeed contains several notable improvements from the PTA as safeguards against torture and ill-treatment. Yet they are inadequate in light of the applicable international standards as well as the dark history of torture and other ill-treatment associated with Sri Lanka’s counter-terrorism regime. Although the PTA may be repealed, its fraught legacy may nevertheless remain in practice if comprehensive safeguards against torture are not in place.
The current counter-terrorism regime has a concerning history of torture and ill-treatment relating to its notorious provision that expressly provides for confessions made under the law to be admissible in court. The draft law contains a range of safeguards beginning with the requirement that statements be recorded by magistrates while in compliance with several conditions to ensure their admissibility (Section 60-62). However, it doesn’t contain a general prohibition on the admission of evidence obtained through torture. This has been a recommendation made by the UN human rights bodies over the years. Therefore, it is important that a clear general provision is inserted making any statement or evidence obtained by torture or cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment inadmissible in any proceedings except against a person accused of torture while allocating the burden to the prosecution to prove voluntariness where there is a credible allegation of torture.
A further provision intended to be a safeguard is the framework that PSTA provides for the detainee’s next of kin or the attorney to access the place where the detainee is held. The draft law requires the next of kin of the suspect to be notified within 24 hours from such arrest (Section 25). It also requires that the suspects arrested under the PTA should (among other things) be informed of the right to access an attorney (Section 21). In practice, the protection appears less robust when viewed together with another provision tucked within the same legislation. Section 32 requires that the next of kin or the attorney can only enter a place of detention with prior approval from the Officer in Charge. This effectively places the decision to grant access in the hands of the detaining authority. In practice, this can delay early access to lawyers and family, increasing the risk of torture and contradicting the Rules 58 and 61 of the Nelson Mandela Rules.
Another aspect that may require safeguards to comply with the Nelson Mandela Rules is the power granted to the magistrate to allow detainees to be held in police custody under conditions including isolation. According to the PSTA, a detainee can be held in isolation up to two weeks at a time and up to three months when taken together. The Nelson Mandela Rules require that solitary confinement can only be a measure of last resort for no more than 15 consecutive days, subject to independent review. Therefore, it is important that safeguards are placed to make sure that this is not used to facilitate lengthy isolation of detainees in practice.
Risk of extended detention with limited judicial oversight
Sri Lanka’s counter-terrorism regime faced criticism over decades for lengthy periods of detention with insufficient review by the judiciary, creating circumstances that increased the risk of torture and other violence. This was particularly seen as incompatible with the Article 9 of the ICCPR. Although the PSTA has attempted to address this, the lack of safeguards could still facilitate extended detention with minimum judicial oversight in practice. The most notable issue here is the absence of discretion for magistrates to confirm or deny a detention order. Under Section 27, a magistrate has no alternative action except confirming the detention order. This removes the required judicial oversight to decide the legality of detention, subjecting detainees to long term administrative detention, increasing their vulnerability to torture and ill-treatment.
Effects of the immunity clause
Section 70 of the draft PSTA contains another broad provision that may be problematic. It grants immunity for acts performed in good faith while exercising due diligence, reasonable care and skill. These claims of good faith and due diligence could potentially in practice be raised as grounds for immunity, which is concerning from a human rights perspective. If used in the context of torture, this clause will not align with the absolute prohibition of torture, particularly in Articles 2(3) and 12 of the CAT. According to the absolute prohibition, countries should ensure that there are no exceptional justification or immunity preventing the investigation or prosecution of torture. Even if this immunity clause is not used to justify torture or other ill-treatment in court, it may still affect the way the officers understand the limits of their conduct in practice.
Old wine in a new bottle?
The draft PSTA of 2026 appears, on paper at least, to be a slight improvement from the current counter-terrorism framework provided by the PTA when examined from the torture prohibition and prevention perspective. The draft law still lacks safeguards against the institutional and executive abuse of power. Some safeguards included could have little to no effect with the operation of several other provisions of the same law. Therefore, the aimed progress could fall between the cracks of the draft law itself. Without narrow definitions and express prohibitions of torture, undoing the damage from the exposure to four decades of PTA could be unimaginable in practice. The risk of having provisions that appear somewhat human rights compliant on paper but fail in practice is that they could create a false sense of protection, allowing abuses to continue unchecked, making accountability far harder to pursue.